Analyzing Speeches
Return to the SPCH 469A home page
- What elements of the situation does the speech respond to?
- Exigences: Something in the situation demanding response. Long-term or immediate.
- Constraints: Elements of the situation which rhetoric must recognize
- Obstacles to the purpose (the rhetorical problem)
- Opportunities for appeal (the rhetorical possibilities)
- How does the speaker respond to those elements?
- Strategies: Specific plans for addressing exigences and constraints
Return to the Contents of this page
Return to the SPCH 469A home page
Questions framing your analysis
- Descriptive Analysis
- What strategies does the speech use?
- Evaluative Analysis
- How well do those strategies respond to the requirements of the situation?
Return to the Contents of this page
Return to the SPCH 469A home page
- Elements of a Narrative
- Characters: Not just who, but what they are like. What is the character of each?
- Plot Line: Sequence of events
- Protagonist/Antagonist: Struggle is at the center of narrative. Protagonist forces the
action; Antagonist meets with opposition
- Climax: Moment of greatest tension; The turn in the action
- Denouement: Resolution
- Uses of Narrative to a speaker
- Give events a logic
- Identify friends and enemies
- Predict what will happen next; prepares audience for events
- Guide propriety of action
- Give sense of inevitability to events
Return to the Contents of this page
Return to the SPCH 469A home page
The dramatistic process provides motivation for action.
- Order: Shared basis of sense of "rightness"; of justice
- Pollution: Names the violation of that order
- Blame: Fixes responsibility for violation
- Purification: Specifies action being motivated; action to restore order
- Redemption: Motivates by restoration of order through purification
Return to the Contents of this page
Return to the SPCH 469A home page
- Ideographs are terms that take on special power.
- The terms are abstract. Examples: <Democracy> <Liberty> < Freedom>
- They invoke ideology, beliefs and attitudes. <Liberty> is a word that we can invoke
to protect ourselves from the powerful. It is a term that is invoked to help us sort out
friendly nations from not-friendly nations. We cannot point to liberty. We can point to
other things -- a newspaper criticizing the government -- and call it <liberty>.
- They are historically grounded. Ideographs generally have historical narratives that
tell us of the importance of our embracing the action principles of the ideograph. For
example, we tell the story of the Alamo as about Texans' fight for liberty. The Statue
of Liberty serves as a focal point for ancestors who came to this country seeking
<liberty>.
- They have an energy to motivate action. We invoke ideographs to shape action,
behavioral complexes of people working toward ends.
- <Colonialism> as an ideograph
- Colonialism was initially an economic system. Colonial countries were owned by
the mother country and operated for its benefit. Initially they were seen as a place to
extract raw materials, later as exclusive markets to sell the manufacturing goods of the
mother country.
- Became a powerful ideograph in the 1960s. African nations were achieving
independence from their colonial masters. The movement was being celebrated with a
narrative of the people living under colonialism oppressed by the colonial masters.
(Notice the slave metaphor.) So, the freedom granted to previously colonial nations
became a way of talking about the aspirations of people talking about their oppression
and the anti-colonial movement in Africa became a beacon of hope for these people.
- The antiwar rhetoric opposed to Vietnam presented it as a war to retain an
American colony.
- Those in the Black Power movement found the ideograph a way to talk about
their own aspirations.
- The strategic use of ideograph
- Ideographs used in discourse bring the full weight of certain beliefs and attitudes
of the culture to bear on a particular situation.
- Because ideographs invoke central value systems they have powerful motivational
force.
Return to the Contents of this page
Return to the SPCH 469A home page