The
Six Sensitivities that Characterize a Sound Rhetorical Analysis
Purpose
Rhetors attempt to accomplish
objectives with discourse. Sensitive rhetorical analysts identify
purposes of the rhetor and his/her audience.
A Standard Typology
of Rhetorical Purposes
- To provide information
- To join in, or to
induce, some action
- To change people’s
minds
- To bond or form some
cooperative group
In analyzing purpose
- Look for Multiple
Purposes: Any one rhetorical act may have several purposes
- Look for a Hierarchy
of Purposes: Some purposes facilitate more central purposes.
- Analyze both rhetor
or audience purposes
Analyzing Purpose on
the Internet
- Benum organizes her
book into chapters that develop a typology of internet purpose
- Identifying the sponsor’s
purpose begins rhetorical analysis
- Always keep in mind:
- “What is the
sponsor trying to achieve?”
“What is the user
trying to achieve in visiting the site?”
Audience
No notion is more central
to rhetorical sensitivity that thinking about communication in
terms of the audience. Rhetorical analysis always views decisions
from the perspective of an an analysis of the audience.
Questions guiding a
rhetorical analysis of audience:
- Who is the audience?
- What interests them?
- What do they value?
- What do they know?
- What do they believe?
- What are their goals?
Methods for answering
these questions:
-
Demographics:
Generalizations about categories of social affiliation. Demographic
analysis is an approach to understanding the character of
an audience. Demographic characteristics can be easily observed
or inferred. Among the important demographic categories are:
- Age
- Educational
Level
- Geographic
(including region of the country and urban/rural/suburban)
- Socio-economic
status
- Sex
-
Religion
-
Cultural Analysis:
Begins by identifying the public with whom the audience will
engage in discourse. What is their media of communication?
Who will they listen to and talk to in response to the situation/topic?
This public may constitute a subculture or the more general
culture. It may be particular to this topic.
- Listening:
There is no substitute for listening carefully to the users
talk.
Audience for the internet
are your users
You must know your users,
their needs, wants, values, goals. Benum's method of developing
persona as a way of summarizing your analysis of the audience seems
particularly appropriate.
Strategy
The rhetorical planning
of a messages is built around a sensitivity to strategy. One formulates
a goal and a strategy to achieve it. All the decisions that go into
preparing a message are viewed strategically in a rhetorically sensitive
analysis.
- Rhetorical decisions
need not be conscious nor intentional. Strategy refers to viewing
them in terms of achieving goals. Decisions are instrumental:
microgoals and how to achieve them.
- Rhetorical strategies
relate to modes of presentation. All the decisions that go into
forming communication are viewed strategically.
- A rhetorically sensitive
analysis can describe the decisions that shape the message and
support those decisions in the purpose and audience of the message.
- A rhetorically sensitive
analysis evaluates the decisions in terms of the analysis of
the audience and the purpose.
Interest
Rhetors always compete with distractions. In a speech, the average
human attention span is about 7 seconds. A rhetorically sensitive
communicator is always aware of the interest of his audience.
Strategies for holding
interest: Strategies for holding interest may be found in:
- Subject matter
- Flows without escape.
Patterns such as narrative that carry the audience through the
communication without a convenient exit.
- Need to know. Messages
may provide a motivation for listening.
- Drama (conflict
or uncertainty of outcome). Audiences are held longer to situations
of conflict and uncertainty.
- Novelty. The different
will hold attention longer than the familiar.
Holding Interest on
the Internet
- The problem of interest
on the internet begins with its character as a pull rather than
push technology. That is, audiences come to websites my requesting
them. Therefore, there must be a reason to visit and a path
to visit.
- Once the user has
come to the site, surfing away is fast and natural. There must
be strategies to hold interest.
- Rhetorically sensitive
design will use some of the strategies above to hold the interest
of the user.
- Audience analysis
must reveal strategies for holding interest among users.
Clarity
Rhetorical analysis is
sensitive to how to communicate clearly to the audience.
Common obstacles to
clarity
- Terminology. Technical
words create distance between the rhetor and the audience and
prevent understanding.
- Unfamiliar ideas.
The more novel the ideas the heavier the demands that the ideas
be clear.
- Degree of complexity.
The more complex the ideas, the more difficult clarity will be
to achieve.
Strategies to achieve clarity
- Content strategies.
Examples are provding definitions, illustrations, or clarifying
with a familiar analogy.
- Format strategies.
Examples are the use of visuals, tables, or maps.
Achieving Clarity on
Websites
- You must first understand
the obstacles to clarity.
- What terminology may
your users not understand?
- What ideas central
to your presentation of material are unfamiliar to your users?
- Then you select strategies
to clarify.
- Content strategies.
What content can you provide to clarify concepts or information?
- Format strategies.
How can you best present the material visually?
Hyperlinks. What material
will be on the page and what linked? Hyperlinks are particularly
useful with multiple audiences.
Appeal
Rhetorically sensitive
communication always understands how it will modify its content
and approach to appeal to its audience.
Constructing Messages
with Appeal
- Knowing your audience:
What are the audience’s interests? Beliefs? Values? What
is important to them? What do they want to know?
- Adapt to your audience:
How can you better connect your material to your audience? What
is the strategy for this particular audience?
Appeal and the Internet
- Your first question
is always: Who are my users?
- Then you must determine:
What will they find appealing?
- How does my purpose
relate to the things they find appealing?
- How can my page present
itself in an appealing way?
Your choices of content
and design are always justified by your analysis of audience.
|