Processes, Vocabulary, and Systems of Vocabulary

Exam II

Basic terms in argumentative analysis

These are terms guiding your analysis of argument.

Basic Terms

Argument1
Argument2

Rhetorical Argument
Claim
Reason
Support
Critical Attitude
Logical Analysis
Audience Analysis
Enthymeme

Analyzing Argument2

Things you should be able to do: Terms you should know: Arranged in a system of vocabulary
Identify the proposition of an argument2 Proposition
Thesis
Claim
Level of claim
Identify the type of proposition Fact
Judgment (value)
Action (policy)
Type of claim

Identify potential issues three different ways

  • your knowledge of subject matter of proposition
  • from the rhetorical situation
  • using stock issues
Issue
potential issue
stock issue

Stock issues for propositions of judgement

Stock issues for propositions of policy

Identify actual issues in argument2 from two different sources

  • presented by speakers
  • of concern to audience

actual issues

 
Assess the argument1s for sufficiently addressing issues    
Identify the choices an arguer makes in presenting his/her argument Constructive argument
Refutation
1 sided argument
2 sided argument
Propositional argument
Generalized support
Precise argument
Enumeration

Choices for presentation of argument

Analyzing Argument1

You learned three ways to analyze argument1. You should be able to employ all three methods.

Things you should be able to do: Terms you should know: Systems of vocabulary

Isolate the claim of an argument

  • Thesis of a message
  • Claim of an individual argument
Proposition
Thesis
Claim
Chain reasoning
Multiple Support
Implicit Claims
Levels of claim

Evaluate the argument with the Toulmin model, using

  • logical analysis (warranted for you)
  • audience analysis (warranted for audience)

to claim
to support
to warrant

The Toulmin model
Evaluate the argument by identifying fallacies fallacy
Appeal to inertia
Ad hominem
Name calling
Glittering Generalities
Guilt by Association
Plain folks appeal
Ad misericordium or appeal to sympathy
Ad populum
Appeal to ignorance

Red Herring
Straw target
False dilemma
Fallacy of composition
Fallacy of division
Ad verecundiam
Post hoc ergo prompter hoc
Fallacies
Locate the source of credibility for evidence offered as support primary evidence
secondary evidence
enthymatic evidence
direct evidence
Source of credibility in evidence

Evaluate the argument by identifying the type of evidence and evaluating the evidence

example
analogy
sign
statistics
authority
Types of support used to warrant claims
Internal consistency
External validity
Corroboration
Bias
General tests of evidence
  Tests of Stories
Tests of Visuals
Tests of Statistics
Tests of Analogies
Tests of Authority

Analyzing Organization

In this unit you learned to recognize and use organizational devices in interpreting a message.

Things you should be able to do: Terms you should know: Systems of vocabulary
Identify the thesis of a message    
Divide a message into its parts and analyze each part Part
Introduction
Body
Conclusion
Parts of a message
Identify the pattern of organization linking the parts

Chronological Pattern
Topical Pattern
Cause-Effect Pattern
Problem-Solution Sequence
Motivated Sequence

Patterns of organization

Analyzing Narrative

In this unit you learned to understand the power of narrative.

Things you should be able to do: Terms you should know: Systems of vocabulary
Describe a narrative found in a message

Character
Plot line
Protagonist/Antagonist
Climax
Denouement

Structure of Narrative
Evaluate a narrative   Strategic evaluation
Logical evaluation

Analyzing Visuals

In this unit you learned to understand that visuals are also strategic.

Things you should be able to do: Terms you should know: Systems of vocabulary
Analyze the strategic dimensions of the visual

Selection
Spatial Placement
Temporal Placement
Size
Motion
Interaction

Strategic dimensions of visual
Place the strategic dimensions into the context of the medium of communication Newspapers
Magzines
TV Advertising
TV News
Web Pages
The various visual media
Analyze the strategies for using visual in the message

communication as information
communication as form

Use the systems you have learned to this point to analyze the strategic planning of the visual artifact.