Teaching Visual Culture: Integrating Feminist Pedagogies

Annotated Bibliography of Key Texts

 

The Feminism and Visual Culture Reader. Amelia Jones, Editor. (Routledge: 2003).
This text assembles an important collection of writings addressing visual fields such as art, film, popular culture, and new media from a feminist perspective, combining now-classic essays with provocative new pieces. Complicating the notion of feminism as a unified discourse, the volume explores how issues of race, class, nationality and sexuality enter into debates about feminism in the field of the visual. Included are stakeholders from across the spectrum of feminism including academics, critics, artists and activists. It includes six previously unpublished texts written specifically for this volume and introductory essays to each of the thematic sections: Representation; Difference; Disciplines/Strategies; Mass Culture/Media Interventions; Body; and Technology. The "Feminism and Visual Culture Reader" provides an overview of major feminist approaches to the visual and supplies a framework within which to analyze shifts and new developments in feminist theorizing about visual culture over the period of the past thirty years. It will be an anchor text in this course for the identification of feminist epistemologies with respect to the visual and will serve as a point of departure for the production of pedagogical practices for the teaching of visual culture.

 

The Power of Feminist Art: The American Movement of the 1970s, History and Impact. Norma Broude and Mary Garrard, Editors. (Harry N. Abrams: 1996).
This anthology assembles an important collection of essays addressing the history of the feminist movement in the art world of the United States, and its subsequent impact on both feminism and art. Included as authors are representatives from across the spectrum of American feminism including academics, critics, and the artists themselves. Divided into thematic sections, each of which proceeds according to an approximate historical chronology, the introduction by the editors is followed by: Seeds of Change: Feminist Art and Education in the Early Seventies; Building a Network: Feminist Activism in the Arts; Challenging Modernism: The Facets of Feminist Art; and Beyond the Seventies: The Impact of Feminist Art. The "Power of Feminist Art" provides an overview of major feminist developments within and around U.S. visual culture from the inception of the so-called second wave feminist movement, tracing and contexualizing the contours and trajectories of its manifestations in art, a movement in feminism that had not yet been documented. It will complement "The Feminism and Visual Culture Reader" as an important additional source of theory about a specific feminist moment in the arts. It will provide a rich source of more particularlzed information, including visual reproductions, with which to ground our thinking about how to develop a vocabulary and set of practices for looking at representation through the lens of feminist pedagogy.

 

Guerrilla Girls and publications by The Guerrilla Girls:

 

Talking Visions: Multicultural Feminism in a Transnational Age. Ella Shohat, Editor. (MIT Press: 1998).
This anthology originated out of the New Museum of Contemporary Art's Documentary Sources in American Art series. Convened as a sequence of panels and discussions entitled Cross Talk: A Multicultural Feminist Symposium, the original papers from the July 1993 event were adapted by the authors and editor for this publication. Presenters -- academics as well as visual and performance artists -- include bell hooks, Adrian Piper, Coco Fusco, Tricia Rose, Caren Kaplan, Inderpal Grewal, Chandra Talpade Mohanty and Carmelita Tropicana. The volume is generously illustrated.

 

Joyce J. Scott: Kitckin' It with the Old Masters. (The Baltimore Museum of Art/Maryland Institute, College of Art: 2000).
This exhibition, curated by George Ciscle, is handsomely reproduced in a folio edition that includes Scott's images, a community album, exhibition checklist, artist chronology and essays by Leslie King-Hammond, Mel Watkins, Mary Jane Jacob, and Keith Morrison.

 

National Gallery of Art, Washington (Cd-Rom: ©2003).
This digital text will be read equally for its emergent and reductive pedagogical practices. The user has more than 1,500 works of art drawn from the permanent collection of the National Gallery of Art, Washington at her disposal in an interactive program based on the Gallery's onsite multimedia Micro Gallery. High quality reproductions of the work of more than 600 artists are represented in technologies that permit variant formats and closely observed studies of the images. Additional features include a subject index, a timeline, an atlas and a dictionary of art terms. A multi-user platform, this version (1.2) of the Cd-Rom is formatted for both Microsoft Windows® and Apple® Macintosh®. These selected works will be excellent comparative material for reading against and in conjunction with the Guerrilla Girls' texts. At the same time, the technology can be studied for its multiple knowledge delivery systems and the resulting enrichments available in the learning and teaching environment.

 

The Critical Pedagogy Reader. Antonia Darder, Rodolfo D. Torres and Marta Baltadano, Editors. (Routledge: 2002).
This reader includes selections from major theorists in the field of critical pedagogy, including Paolo Freire, Henry Giroux, Peter McLaren, bell hooks, Michelle Fine and Michael Apple. The essays are arranged thematically around the issues of racism, class, gender and sexuality, language and literacy and social change. A case study is offered at the beginning of each section to connect the theory to a practical classroom situation and each section concludes with a number of critical questions for analysis. Students will read selections from this text as an introduction to key pedagogical concepts and to the range of issues to be considered when implementing new pedagogies.

 

Working the Ruins: Feminist Poststructural Theory and Methods in Education. Elizabeth A. Pierre and Wanda S. Pillow, Editors. (Routledge: 2000).
This anthology, which contains essays by Patricia Hill Collins, Wendy Brown, Patti Lather and Lubna Nazir Chaudhry, among others, is concerned with the effect of poststructuralism on feminist approaches to research and pedagogy. Theorizing from a variety of disciplinary spaces, topics include ethnography, black feminist thought, Latina writing, identities, and the use of technologies, discourses and bodies as potentially destabilizing sites of deconstructive practice.

 

The Visual Culture Reader. Nicholas Mirzoeff, Editor. (Routledge: 1998).
Three introductory essays by Nicholas Mirzoeff, Irit Rogoff, and Ella Shohat and Robert Stam open this anthology. The body of the text is organized in six major parts (each with an introduction by Mirzoeff): A Genealogy of Visual Culture: From Art to Culture; Visual Culture and Everyday Life; Virtuality: Virtual Bodies, Virtual Spaces; Race and Identity in Colonial and Postcolonial Culture; Gender and Sexuality; and Pornography. This and the Hall/Evans anthology which follows will be useful texts to compare and contrast with the feminist approach to visual culture analysis taken by Jones in the Feminism and Visual Culture Reader.


Visual Culture: The Reader.
Jessica Evans and Stuart Hall, Editors. (Sage Publications: 1999).

The sectional headings in this anthology are: Cultures of the Visual; Regulating Photographic Meanings; and Looking and Subjectivity.

 

Words of Fire: An Anthology of African-American Feminist Thought. Beverly Guy Sheftfall, Editor. (New Press: 1995).
This anthology documents the continuous, evolving, feminist presence in the nonfiction writing of African American women from the early nineteenth century to the present. Most of these texts are previously published but not widely available, particularly in anthology form. Black Feminism is defined and illustrated across seven sections, each introduced by editor Sheftall. The seven chapters are: Beginnings: In Defense of our Race and Sex; Triumph and Tribulation, Defining Black Womanhood; Civil Rights and Women’s Liberation; Beyond the Margins: Black Women Claiming Feminism; The Body Politic: Sexuality, Violence and Reproduction; Reading the Academy; and Discourses of Resistance: Interrogating Black Nationalist Ideologies
.

Visibly Female: Feminism and Art: An Anthology. Hilary Robinson, Editor. (Camden Press: 1987).
An excellent supplementary source of writings by and about feminist artists in the 70s and 80s U.S. movement, this anthology is a part of the larger Women on Art series. Organized into four sections, the selections include: Personal Statements, Interviews, Reviews and Overviews, and Theory.

 

Daughters of the Dust (1991: 113 min.) and Illusions (1983: 34 min.), Julie Dash, writer, producer and director.
These two films will allow us to focus on how visual culture produced by women of color is constructed within traditional discourse by looking at how critics and audiences respond to the circulation of images of women of color by women of color. Dash's work will also be analyzed by students for emergent forms of knowledge claims and knowledge production. Students will collaborate to create pedagogical strategies for teaching this material.

 

Gender and Education, Vol. 14, No. 2 (2002). "Does the Use of Journals as a Form of Assessment put into Practice Principles of Feminist Pedagogy?" by Valerie A. Clifford. (pp. 109-121).
Journal writing has become a popular form of assessment in some disciplinary fields, particularly those that are informed by feminist pedagogies. The author of this article analyzed the learning journals of a class of teaching students to determine what pedagogical practices they reflected. The journals and the processes surrounding their use were found to embrace many of the principals of both critical and feminist pedagogy. In addition, they were found to be a useful vehicle for the development of a reflexive educational practice. Social justice issues, on the whole, however, were found to surface primarily in the journals of teachers whose classes were explicitly involved the discussion of these topics, reflecting a tension between respecting the rights of learners to construct their own knowledge and the desire to guide their attention more explicitly to issues of equity and equality. This article, in combination with journal writing requirements for the course, will allow students to consider the implementation of this pedagogical practice and the implications of journal writing/teaching practices in the feminist oriented visual arts classroom.

 

Women's Studies Quarterly. Vol. 24 (Fall/Winter 1996). "Curriculum Transformation: a brief overview" by Elaine Hedges. (pp. 16-22).
As part of a special issue on curriculum mainstreaming of women's studies scholarship in community colleges, the writer offers an overview of curriculum transformation, as defined in this instance by the process of faculty incorporating new scholarship on women into their courses. She discusses the effects of such projects on faculty -- including changes in the courses, changes in pedagogy, and professional change -- as well as the effects on students. This article will be used to help students conceptualize the parameters of undertaking such a project in teaching within the visual arts.

 

Women's Studies Quarterly. Vol. 24 (Fall/Winter 1996). "Feminist Pedagogy and techniques for the changing classroom" by Shirley C. Parry. (pp. 45-54).
As part of a special issue on curriculum mainstreaming of women's studies scholarship in community colleges, the writer discusses how feminist pedagogical techniques can be used effectively in traditional as well as computerized classroom environments (a special interest of mine). She describes exercises and techniques used in feminist pedagogy, including group collaboration techniques, that encourage students to apply principles of feminist group processes in large class discussions and small group collaborations alike.

 

Teachers College Record. 101.1 (Fall 1999). "Progessive Education and Feminist Pedagogies: Issues in Gender, Power, and Authority" by Frances A. Maher. (p. 35-39).
This article explores several problems with the application of progressive, student-centered educational theory to gender issues in the classroom, including the construction of the female teacher's authority.

 

Review of Education/Pedagogy/Cultural Studies. 24.3 (July/Sept. 2002). "Just Discourse: The Limits of Truth for the Discourse of Social Justice" by Lee Quinby. (pp. 235-49).
Taking a cue from the current popularity of reality television, the author theorizes its implications for and influence on the increasing denigration of modern cultural discourse, definining it as a space that is empty of social justice rhetoric. Quinby argues for the possibilities of considering and discussing social justice in these mediated cultural spaces, asserting that such alternative formats can actually facilitate more equitable ways of thinking, speaking and acting. The limits of truth, the development of freedom and the role of feminism in a freedom-based concept of justice are discussed in ways that facilitate the consideration of contemporary cultural and artistic production as part of a creatively emergent/resistant emancipatory discourse.

 

Canadian Journal of Education. Vol. 24, No. 1 (Winter 1999). "Beyond dualism: toward a dialogic negotiation of difference" by Rishma Dunlop. (pp. 57-69).
Abstract: The author explores the development of a critical pedagogy that interrogates commonly held assumptions about identity and culture in social, political, and historical perceptions of cultural difference. She attempts to deconstruct dichotomizing tendencies of thinking about differences, with the aim to position thinking instead along the borderlands or on the fault line between cultures, a 'third space' in which to live critically. She examines the perspectives of critical consciousness, third-space positionings, and dialogic negotiations of differences through the lenses of feminist theory, narrative enquiry, and literary theory to suggest how these perspectives may lead to cross-cultural identification or understandings in the post-secondary classroom.

 

Educational Theory. Vol. 46 (Summer 1996). "Feminist pedagogy theory: reflections on power and authority" by Carmen Luke. (pp. 283-302).
Abstract: The writer explores some of the tensions and contradictions within feminist pedagogy and examines feminist work in the academy. She argues that the conceptual logic and political practice of opposition in feminist pedagogy to the male legacy of authority, power, and knowledge have consequences for women that are potentially self-invalidating and politically disabling. It is time to develop a kind of anti-confessional pedagogy that would seek theoretically to bring together the seductive dynamics of knowledge, the engendered embodiment of teacher and student, and the performativity of teaching with an ethics grounded in the resistance to abusive power and social injustices. It is necessary for feminists to disengage from their anxieties about authority and power. It is necessary to take authority, to acknowledge and theorize the power that is variously exercised and to resist the hidden hegemony of feminism itself -- that which keeps feminists from constructively criticizing some of feminism's most cherished tenets.